Not investment advice. This page tallies public stock calls posted on X and scores how they turned out. It does not recommend any trade.
Summary
- Scoreboard: Day Trading. Updated October 15, 2026.
- What counts: calls tagged intraday or swing, plus all share calls from accounts we track as day traders.
- Win rule: A day-trade call wins if the stock closes in the called direction (vs the last close before the post) on the first close after the post, or on any of the next 5 trading-day closes. Intraday-tagged calls use only the first close.
- Scored calls so far: 1. Calls still inside their scoring window: 3.
- Status: building track record. No caller has 15 scored day trading calls yet, so nobody is ranked. We do not assign ranks before that.
MCAFax House Record
| Caller | Scored calls | W-L | Win % | Calls still being scored |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MCAFax Top Trades (house picks) | 0 | 0-0 | N/a | 10 |
MCAFax's picks are scored with the same rule as everyone else on this page, misses included. MCAFax is shown separately and is never ranked against the callers whose votes produce its picks.
Ranked Callers
No ranked callers yet (building track record).
Building Track Record
Callers below have fewer than 15 scored calls in this category. Their numbers are shown as recorded, without a rank.
| Caller | Scored calls | W-L | Calls still being scored | Top Trades status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colin King (@valuedontlie) | 1 | 1-0 | 0 | Building |
| Paul J. Singh (@PaulJSingh) | 0 | 0-0 | 2 | Building |
| CtheLightTrading (@canuck2usa) | 0 | 0-0 | 1 | Building |
| Adam Mancini (@AdamMancini4) | 0 | 0-0 | 0 (Tracked since 2026-10-15) | Building |
| Nathan Michaud (@InvestorsLive) | 0 | 0-0 | 0 (Tracked since 2026-10-15) | Building |
| Heisenberg (@Mr_Derivatives) | 0 | 0-0 | 0 (Tracked since 2026-10-15) | Building |
| Brian Shannon, CMT (@alphatrends) | 0 | 0-0 | 0 (Tracked since 2026-10-15) | Building |
| Ripster (@ripster47) | 0 | 0-0 | 0 (Tracked since 2026-10-15) | Building |
Methodology
- Source. We log public calls from X accounts we track into the MCAFax Market Calls database: post link, time, ticker, direction, and for options the type, strike and expiry exactly as stated.
- Starting price. The last close at or before the post time, so a pre-market post cannot take credit for that morning's move.
- Win rule. A day-trade call wins if the stock closes in the called direction (vs the last close before the post) on the first close after the post, or on any of the next 5 trading-day closes. Intraday-tagged calls use only the first close.
- Separate scoreboards. Day Trading, Options and Long-Term are scored on their own horizons. A call counts on one scoreboard only.
- Ranking. A caller needs 15 scored calls in this category to be ranked. Order: shrunk win rate (wins + 5) / (scored calls + 10), which keeps a lucky short streak from topping the table.
- Top Trades status. With 15+ scored calls, a caller is positive if the shrunk win rate (wins + 5) / (scored + 10) is above 50%, otherwise negative (consensus only). Fewer than 15 = building. Positive and building callers can put a trade on Top Trades; negative callers only add a 0.15 consensus bonus (0.50 max in total) when they agree with a positive caller and never subtract. Status is recomputed every trading day, so a caller whose record turns positive regains full weight automatically.
- Refresh. Rescored every trading day after the close. Nothing is estimated; a call with no price data is left unscored.
Not investment advice. Past results do not predict future ones.